Deadline nears on churches’ court appeal
Dec 17th, 2009 by David
From BC Local News
Churches involved in a battle with the Diocese of New Westminster over same-sex blessings have not yet decided whether to appeal a B.C. Supreme Court decision that ruled against them.
The four churches, including St. Matthew’s Anglican in Abbotsford, have until Dec. 29 to launch an appeal. Representatives met Monday to discuss the situation, but delayed a decision until at least next week.
Cheryl Chang, who serves as legal counsel, and is a member of one of the churches (St. John’s Shaugnessy in Vancouver), said the decision has been postponed pending the results of a special vestry meeting this Sunday at St. Matthias and St. Luke in Vancouver.
She said all clergy and trustees involved in the matter want to ensure their congregations have a say on whether to appeal the decision announced Nov. 25.
Another meeting will be scheduled next week with representatives from the four churches.
Chang said there are clear grounds for an appeal, which can be filed now and discontinued at a later time. However, if the deadline is missed there is no other opportunity.
Rev. Mike Stewart, rector of St. Matthew’s Church, said the congregation there is still considering its options.
“We’re still in the process of prayer and discernment,” he said.
Justice Stephen Kelleher ruled that the four parishes involved in the case are using church properties “outside the jurisdiction of the diocese,” which supports same-sex blessings.
The four parishes have maintained that allowing same-sex blessings is contrary to core Anglican doctrine. They broke away from the Anglican Church of Canada in February 2008 to join the Anglican Network in Canada (ANiC).
Clergy and trustees were asked by the diocese to vacate the churches, but they have refused to do so.
The fourth church involved is Church of the Good Shepherd in Vancouver.

Due to a death in the family I am not at home at this time. However, I consider it a duty to make the following statements with respect to any appeal.
1. The argument has been made that Christians do not go to court with Christians. In this situation it is clear we are not dealing with Christians but rather apostates. To be a Christian mandates that one accepts the authority of Scripture and the uniqueness of Jesus Christ. Michael Ingham and his cohorts accept neither. Therefore we are not going to court with Christians.
2. Our Chancellor, Ms. Cheryl Chang, is both an excellent lawyer and a committed Christian. I am fully confident she would not recommend any appeal if she did not believe there are excellent grounds for same. Yes, there could be costs involved but I believe we are called to follow any recommendations she might make. This is not a time for “arm chair legal experts” but rather a careful review of those who are really experts.
Continue to pray for discernment and for our legal team and also for the priests and parishioners involved.
Oh no, and so close to Christmas. My prayers and sympathies to you and yours.